Our creamy Mackinac Island Fudge comes from our original recipes developed by Don & Katy Kilwin. Having purchased a marble table in 1948 Don Kilwin began hand-crafting fudge shortly thereafter. Over the years we have added many flavors that are enjoyed in all of our stores and throughout the country. We think it was the best fudge ever made then and the best you'll ever enjoy today! Chocolate is our #1 Top Seller, but also try our signature Turtle Fudge and one of our other top sellers, Sea-Salt Caramel Fudge! In store pricing may vary. Shop Fudge.